Journal

Why some houses feel right before you’ve seen the kitchen

That instant sense that a house could be home is easy to put down to chemistry. Some of it is simpler than that, and worth understanding.

attractive-front-door

Being impressed by a room is not quite the same as feeling at home in it.

“I knew as soon as I walked in.”

Buyers say it often, more than you might think, and usually a little apologetically, as if instinct were not quite a sensible way to choose a home. They tend to say it before they have opened a cupboard or asked about the boiler. The kitchen gets its turn later, and by then something has usually been decided.

I think that instinct deserves more credit than it gets. Architects and researchers have explored why certain spaces appeal to us. Some of their findings fit with what I’ve seen on viewings.

Back in the seventies, Christopher Alexander argued in A Pattern Language that people gravitate towards rooms with light on two sides. His evidence came from informal observation. Still, the explanation is appealing. Light from two directions reduces glare and makes faces easier to read. Think of the room everyone drifts into without quite knowing why: a corner sitting room, or a kitchen with a side window as well as one onto the garden.

Height changes our impression, too. A study led by Oshin Vartanian found that people were more likely to judge high-ceilinged rooms beautiful, and the same went for open rooms over enclosed ones. Shown an enclosed room, they were also more inclined to say they would leave. The participants were lying in a brain scanner looking at photographs, so the findings say more about first impressions than about living somewhere. And being impressed by a room is not quite the same as feeling at home in it.

Then there is what lies beyond the window. In a small study published in Science in 1984, Roger Ulrich compared the records of 46 surgical patients. Those looking onto trees had shorter hospital stays and took fewer strong painkillers than those facing a brick wall. Hospital recovery is a different question from choosing a home, but it suggests the view doesn’t have to be spectacular. It could just be a tree outside the kitchen window.

A good view also needs somewhere to enjoy it from. Jay Appleton’s prospect and refuge theory offers one explanation for the pull of the window seat, the inglenook and the kitchen table facing the garden: the appeal of being sheltered while still being able to see out.

A great deal of the money and thought that goes into homes is spent opening them up, and a large kitchen and living space can work beautifully. But people also want somewhere to settle within it. A low sitting room under old beams can feel more like home than a grand space with nowhere in particular to be, even if it loses out in photographs.

Around Marlow, Cookham and Bourne End, some homes have that combination in their setting: an outlook towards the river, an expansive lawn with a sprinkling of mature trees. The prospect and the refuge are there before anyone has unpacked a box.

Kitchens can be ripped out and boilers replaced, but much of what makes a house feel right is already there.

The kitchen can wait.

Dennis de Bono

Written by Dennis de Bono

Independent estate agent, Marlow, Cookham and Bourne End