The more surprising point is that off-market selling isn't necessarily about selling off-market.
There is a particular pressure that comes with putting a home on the open market. The photographs are out, the price is public, and a quiet fortnight can suddenly feel much longer. Even a seller who has time on their side can begin to feel that something ought to be happening.
That is one reason I think the first step deserves more thought than simply choosing a date to go onto Rightmove.
For me, off-market selling is most useful as a considered stage before a public launch. That means approaching suitable buyers and buying agents, sharing details by agreement and arranging viewings without a public listing. It can be a useful first stage, with a wider campaign ready to follow if needed.
Whether I would suggest it depends on the move the owner wants to make. Someone working to a tight timescale may need the reach of a public launch straight away. Someone with flexibility might appreciate the chance to explore interest with fewer viewings and less disruption, particularly where privacy matters.
There may also be something useful to learn. With an individual house and few obvious comparisons, early reactions can help test assumptions about the asking price and reveal how buyers see the property alongside the alternatives they're considering.
An ambitious price can be explored at this stage before the home acquires a public marketing history. It still needs a credible basis. Keeping a property quiet does nothing to make an unrealistic figure more achievable.
Occasionally, a buyer may make a strong offer because they want to secure the house before other people see it. For someone who has been looking for a particular kind of home, avoiding the uncertainty of competing later can be attractive. I would be wary, though, of assuming that exclusivity itself creates a premium.
There is an interesting tension here. The buyer values the chance to avoid competition; the seller needs to consider what that competition might have produced. The person who would pay most may be someone I have never spoken to, who would only discover the house through a public launch.
A private offer can meet the seller's objectives without proving what the wider market might have paid. That is worth discussing honestly when an offer arrives. The price matters, but so do the buyer's position, the proposed timing and how well the terms fit the move the seller hopes to make.
Fewer viewings can mean less disruption. They can also mean too little information on which to base a judgement. A handful of reactions deserves attention, but it cannot speak for every buyer who might be interested. Meanwhile, suitable buyers can find other homes while the seller is still deciding what to do.
But perhaps the most overlooked advantage of selling off-market is that it doesn't necessarily need to result in a sale.
Sometimes its greatest value is in preparing the ground for a more effective public launch. Those early conversations can help challenge assumptions about pricing, reveal what buyers particularly value and give us a clearer sense of how to present the home when it reaches the wider market.
That's why I see off-market selling as a stage with something specific to achieve. It might produce an offer the seller is pleased to accept. It might leave us better prepared for a public launch. If it does neither, there is little reason to keep waiting.
The clock may not be visible on a portal, but time is still passing.

Written by Dennis de Bono
Independent estate agent, Marlow, Cookham and Bourne End
